B B Beloved
In an eclectic bar off of Boston Avenue, I met myself. Strung-out. Reeling. The girl before me looked like a caricature, like a child borrowing their older sister’s clothes. Wearing her makeup. Ruining the wax of an expensive lipstick just for a glimpse into another world. Another realm.
I stood in front of her in a hallway that smelt like bergamot and Prosecco. The lights were moody, glowing like faded headlights during a night storm, and the bar was playing a cover of some song I’d heard before, but couldn’t place, sort of like how I couldn’t place myself.
It’d been two weeks since the incident, since Addison had kissed him. Well, I suppose, since I saw her kiss him. There’s a difference, isn’t there – between witnessing something firsthand and simply hearing about it? Speculation. Rumors. Did she or didn’t she? Is she really going to? Would she? All of those indecorous whispers are pinched out like fire from a candle’s wick when you see something. It leaves only the smoke, blurring the lines between real and fake.
How well do you trust your eyes?
How do you know if you’re being honest when you’re the only one in the room?
Questions like this used to keep me up at night. I used to fight sleep like a child. I used to crawl out into my kitchen just to hold the phone’s receiver in my hand. I’d stare at the glowing numbers of the dial pad as if they were some crystal ball. Wipe Addison’s phone number from my brain, I’d plead. Make me forget her. Let me.
It’s a strange thing to love someone, even stranger when that someone is a girl and you’re a girl and you’ve both known one another since first grade. At first, I thought it was platonic – my love for Addison. I used to fantasize about us growing old with one another, but there was never an inclination for marriage or romance. I saw it more as us escaping together. We’d buy a cottage somewhere in the Northeast, raise goats, and host game nights with our friends. She’d paint.
She was a good painter, Addison. She’d won several competitions when we were in high school and had even planned on going to an art school somewhere in Europe. I couldn’t remember where in Europe because she hadn’t told me. You see, the incident had happened this summer before college and afterward, she’d become a ghost.
Although, perhaps phantom is a better word because of its definition: “A figment of the imagination”. My exile had driven me to a sort of madness, clotting the images of her in my mind with a sense of disbelief. Had she really been that close to me all this time? If she had, how could she do such a thing – and why? It was easier to convince myself our friendship had simply been a misunderstanding on my part than it was to accept the truth,
to accept what I’d seen.
Back at the bar, I abandoned myself in the hall and walked into the nearby restroom. Emerald-painted ceilings and dark floral wallpaper greeted me beneath dim lighting. I wobbled, blinking. So far, I’d consumed an entire bottle of Prosecco off an empty stomach and had smoked three stolen cigarettes. My head throbbed. I shut my left eye and then my right, lifting my eyebrows as if the movement would rid me of the pain.
When it didn’t, I stumbled to the toilet in the corner of the room and peed. I washed my hands, splashing water across the floor, my jeans, and the bottom of the mirror across from me. I stuck my head beneath the faucet and opened my mouth. The water was warm and tasted like metal. I drank until I felt like I was going to vomit and then vomited – first, in the sink and then in the toilet.
I was drunk and for girls in college, especially pretty, refined girls like me with nothing but an inheritance behind their name, this was normal. This was expected, however, most pretty, refined girls with nothing but an inheritance behind their name had a hoard of other pretty, refined girls with them. I did not. I never did. And, I’m sure if I had, they’d simply tire of my constant whining.
I was a whiner. Addison used to tell me that. There was nothing in this world I did better than whine. Addison was the light. I was the dark. I liked misery and pain and would anticipate any sort of suffering with an excitement similar to that of a child in line to see an R-rated film. Whining, to me, was the applause after consuming a well-written piece of art. It was proof that life was working. I was alive.
She never understood that.
To her, every bad thing had a purpose. Any wound inflicted on her soul would soon heal and leave her with a better understanding of the world. It was always the destination she worshiped, never the journey. Sometimes, when we were growing up, she’d get this sparkly look in her eyes. We’d be outside playing in the freshly cut grass, the small blades sticking to our bare feet, leaving chlorophyll stains along our ankles and heels, and she’d look otherworldly. Her big, doe eyes would glitter like lake water beneath the sun.
“This is so good.” She’d say. “I love the summer.”
I’d have to catch my breath at the sight of her. How are you real, I’d think. Did you not wriggle out of my brain only to fool me?
When we’d collect bugs in jars, she was always the first to scream. She wanted to let them go.
“If you love something, you let it go. You have to let it be free.” She’d say, and I’d roll my eyes and chew the skin off around my nails.
Always, she begged me to catch them. Butterflies, beetles, flies – you name it, I was catching them because Addison wanted them. We’d argue about setting them free until they eventually died in the jar. We used to cry about it, stare at their little corpses like God. Feel pain. And then we graduated into something else, something apathetic.
I liked squishing the dead beetles between my fingers like they were M&Ms. Addison used to squeal. She’d hit me and tell me to stop, but then, never leave. Hand me the next. Say, “Oh, this one.”, with that same twinkle in her eye. Often, I wondered if we’d trap each other if we had a big enough jar.
I flushed the toilet with a moan and stood to my feet. I cleaned the sink, smeared more of my makeup around my face while wiping the vomit from my lips, and pulled apart the damp pieces of my hair. There was a knock at the door, followed by muffled speech.
“Ugh.” A woman groaned, “Are you almost done in there? I really have to pee.”
I shut my eyes and held onto the sink, feeling as if I was going to vomit again.
The dynamic between Addison and I could be found in nature. She was the more dominant one, the one that made all of the decisions. Kissed all of the boys. She always had things that I wanted – did and said things I wanted. If we were animals, she was the great giant whale and I was the barnacle attached to her stomach. I was the tapeworm in her gut. The lice on her unwashed scalp. And, this point of view wasn’t one-sided. No. She too believed this. It was why she kissed him: Tyler.
My boyfriend.
Now, I know what you’re thinking, why would you have a boyfriend if you’re in love with Addison? There are two parts to that question. First, you have to understand that my love for Addison was anything but practical. It was invasive, gnawing like an esurient termite at my organs. If my body had been composed of wood, surely I’d have collapsed by now.
Secondly, and perhaps, more importantly,
I wanted to see.
All our lives people had told me things like, “Oh, you know Addison said that shirt makes you look fat, right?”, “Are you really friends?”, “Uh…she said you don’t shave your legs.”. It was just like the jars and the bugs and smashing their pathetic, lifeless bodies like candy. Saying one thing and then doing another.
I never liked Tyler, but she did. He was tall and broad. He had big, brown eyes, a crooked smile, and liked acid rock. He was just her type, which meant he was perfect. Addison had never explicitly said that she liked Tyler. We’d just had a few classes with him throughout high school and, occasionally, I’d catch her staring at him.
I’d begun flirting with him our Junior year. He asked me out the summer before Senior year. I told Addison, she was obviously jealous but attempting to hide said jealousy, and then I slept with him. It was awful, the kind of sex that makes you reconsider sex in general. Is the mess really worth it? How come most relationships expect something so miserable? Then, I told Addison and the blotchy rash that coated her skin as she lied about her anger made it worth it. It made me do it again, and again, and again.
I’d tell her about what sort of positions we’d been in or how long he’d last. I’d tell her what he looked like when he came and what sounds he’d make. It felt like I was some neurosurgeon operating on a brain. Every detail I gave her was just another stitch, another poke toward the direction I so wanted her to go.
Then, the summer came and –
The women pounded on the door again. I opened my eyes, feeling the nausea pass, and quickly let her inside. I walked back out into the bar. The music outside of the bathroom was louder than before, that or my headache had worsened. I chose the ladder and stumbled my way out into the alleyway where the bar was located. It was cold and dark. Just lightly, the rain had begun to fall, sheltering everything in a mist. I pulled my jacket on and around myself, burying my chin in the collar.
I smelled like shit, but this was nothing new. Since the incident, I’d taken it upon myself to quit showering. I also stopped shaving, letting one of Addison’s endless lies become a truth. My hair had once been long. I’d cut it three days ago because the mats in it had become unmanageable. Now, it hung just below my cheekbones in a French bob. It made me look eccentric, which I wasn’t.
Often, especially now, I tried to paint my face in such a way that forced people to stare. I don’t know why this was, but I liked the attention. I also liked the act of shopping for makeup, plucking them out of their plastic cubbies, turning them over in my hand like some jewel. My go-to was bright, red lipstick — a ruby lip, if you will, paired with plum eyeshadow with glitter and shading and thick, asymmetrical eyeliner. I’d fall asleep in it every night. I never wanted to be without it, so much that I didn’t mind the clownish girl greeting me in the mirror every morning. Whatever. She just needed a bit of correcting. Don’t we all?
Addison used to say I had a perfectly plain face, that it was easy to draw. She’d smile as she said this too, like her effortless beauty outweighed any sort of negative effect her comment may have had. I didn’t mind. In fact, I enjoyed these back-handed compliments. They often felt like a well I could peer into, some part of her that she’d only ever show me. Because I was special. Because I meant just as much to her as she meant to me. Take a penny. Leave a penny. I used to think these moments were her way of showing me this. We were the same, her and I. Pretenders.
Tyler was the only son of two bankers. He was made of money and owned a boat that he’d take out onto the lake every summer. This summer, he’d invited me out onto the boat and I, purposefully, invited Addison. She’d been single for months, which wasn’t like her. I figured it was because she was secretly seeing Tyler. He’d been unable to make a couple of our dates and she’d been uncharacteristically missing in my life. Rip the bandaid, I thought. Bleed.
But then, she declined. She said she didn’t want to go. So, I went on the stupid boat with Tyler and grilled and drank vintage champagne– all while wondering what ludicrous thing she had to have been doing in place of being on an expensive boat with a beautiful boy in the middle of summer. When we got back, Addison had told me she’d been prepping for school. Apparently, she needed to put together a portfolio and finish off two new original pieces before August. I just told her I understood and she offered to get together for a movie night later that week.
And so, the incident presents itself.
In the alleyway, I kicked a small bit of gravel into a shallow puddle. It clicked against the bottom of the miniature pond. No ripples. Slowly, I crouched down, having spotted a half-smoked cigarette, and brought it to my lips. I lit it with a lighter I’d stolen from Tyler.
Two weeks ago, on a Thursday night, I’d planned to go to Addison’s with Tyler to watch Sabrina. When we arrived, the dated house smelled like chocolate chip cookies and potpourri. Addison had baked all day and had even ordered a pizza from a place down the street. I hugged her in the way we’d always hugged. She kissed my cheek. I kissed her’s. She told me about her day – how her shower had unexpectedly turned cold this morning and that her favorite pair of hose now had a hole in them.
I laughed the way I always laughed. It was genuine, real in a way I wished it not to be. I loved hearing about her day. I loved getting to live within the dust collecting along the shelves of her home – to be trusted with such intimate details.
She started the movie on the box television in the living room. I sat on the floor beside Tyler, wishing he’d just sit on the couch behind us with Addison. The floor was carpet, old carpet, and I’d forgotten then just how painful it became after a few minutes.
I’d gotten up. I said that I needed to use the restroom, that I felt sick. Both Addison and Tyler gave me sympathetic looks but didn’t argue or offer me any remedies. That was good. That was what I planned. I dragged myself into the hallway bathroom and turned on the fan before sitting on the closed toilet. Checking my wristwatch, I made sure to give them enough time alone together.
Even if they didn’t kiss, I could at least gauge the intimacy of their relationship based on how they spoke to one another. If they whispered, then it was obvious. However, if they didn’t – well, I was back to square one. I let ten minutes go by before I turned off the fan. Then, I gently opened the door. The house was dark and all I could hear were the actors in the movie speaking at some elaborate party. I stepped forward. The floor creaked beneath my weight. I stopped.
Barely, I could hear something, something outside of the movie. I walked forward again, this time with more weight shifted to my toes. In the pool of the television light, Addison and Tyler were kissing. She was leaning down from the couch and he was leaning up. Their mouths moved like cows chewing their cud.
I couldn’t breathe.
I was so excited.
Quickly, I stumbled back through the hallway. I needed to calm down, to regroup. If I acted on my excitement, this could go wrong. I could potentially blow the whole thing. In my mind, there were already two outcomes. One: I calmly reentered the living room and pretended as if I knew nothing. After the movie finished, I’d confront them both. I’d make them grovel. I’d make Addison confess and finally accept that I shouldn’t love her. Two: I’d say nothing. Forever.
Acting on my excitement presented a third outcome, one where I ran into the living room while their mouths were still connected and set fire to everything. I didn’t like that outcome. It supplied me with nothing.
Slowly walking backward, I reopened the door to the bathroom, ready to think about my approach. My foot caught on something, though, and I frantically turned on the light. In my reverie, I’d walked too far down the hall. This wasn’t the bathroom. This was just a room. For what, I wasn’t sure.
Gently, I leaned down and set aside the milk crate that I’d tripped on. The carpet was yellow. The walls were paneled. Before me, was a pile of canvases wrapped in white cloth. Paint supplies littered the room. I carefully pulled the cloth from the canvases, letting it fall to the floor like a specter returning to its grave.
Every painting was of me. Every me within the painting was naked or asleep with smeared makeup — a colorful wash, like some lifeless exoskeleton waiting to be malted out of.
Before this moment, I’d never been inside Addison’s studio. I didn’t know she had one. What happened after this discovery, I can’t say. I’m afraid I don’t really remember. Tyler left, though. He ran out of Addison’s front door shortly after I returned to them in the living room. I thought it’d be clever to take off my clothes and cover myself in the same colors Addison had used for all her pieces. I guess I scared him.
Oh, but the look on Addison’s face.
She told me one of those paintings was going to be hung at a bar off of Boston Avenue. When she said this, she was clambering – crying like a baby. I just kept asking her why she hated me and if she hated me so much, why did she paint me? Why did she trap me? Own me. Make me a spectacle and title it, “Beloved”?
She couldn’t answer. Couldn’t…wouldn’t…who’s to say. At the time, I had a couch pillow pressed against her face and was losing my breath. Then, suddenly, she stopped. The world stopped. Everything came to a rushing halt. eerrk. I heard it shake into a stillness like an old, rickety Ferris wheel finally powering down. My head fell to the side at the sight of her dead, soon-to-be cold skin. She looked smaller then, manageable.
In the alleyway, my cigarette came to an end and I hissed, seering the tips of my fingers with a few loose embers. Two girls spilled out from the bar beside me. They were drunk. Friends, I assumed. I watched them for a minute or until one of them spotted me. Her back straightened. Her eyes, glazed, slightly opened just a bit more.
“You’re the girl,” She said. I forced a smile. “You’re the girl in the painting.”
“Hmmm, must’ve escaped.” I hummed, attempting to correct my smeared makeup.
I flicked my cigarette and watched it land in the puddle next to the small bit of gravel.
“Do you know where the artist is then?” She asked. “She was supposed to come tonight.”
I lifted my gaze to her, forcing a frown, “Oh…that’s too bad.”
“You must know her.” The girl continued.
I shook my head, “Hardly.” and then I took a few steps closer to her, squinting to emphasize the process of thought.
She remained where she was, properly drunk – flushed and blotchy and a bit swollen.
“Can I tell you something?” I asked.
She nodded.
I licked my lips, pulling in a deep breath, “I think she’s dead.”
I let my head fall to the side as her eyes widened before me. She understood then. Somehow, she could see Addison’s blood on my hands and place me, effortlessly, at the scene of the crime. It must’ve been something about the way I stared or my face or maybe, it was simply an energy I couldn’t recognize because it was all I’d known.
Her and her friend quickly made up an excuse to go inside. I didn’t move. The rain continued to fall, collecting more and more weight as time went on. I let it wash away the color from my face. I let it soak my clothes. I would’ve killed both those girls. Perhaps that was why Addision had trapped me. From the beginning, she’d been able to see.